A blast from the past.

Look who's turned up on the BBC food boards after a 4-5 years absence. A big "Welcome back" to Zoë Harcombe, who has the site 'Why do you overeat? When all you want is to be slim' and The Harcombe Diet.

We agree on most things. The problem with counting Calories is that, if you reach your Calorie limit by 6pm, what do you do? Spend the rest of the evening hungry and go to bed with a rumbling tummy & hunger pangs? Or just have one teensy-weensy bite to eat, which turns into a "nom-a-thon"? I know what I would do, as I can resist anything.......except temptation!

What we don't agree on is that Calories don't count. I say that they do. So does Lyle McDonald and Anthony Colpo. For people who are restrained to a hospital bed, changing the relative proportions of carbohydrate & fat (keeping protein constant) in their diet makes no difference whatsoever to their long-term weight gain/loss (ignoring glycogen + water weight differences). What it does make a difference to is how much these restrained people would beg for food. On a high-carb diet, I was much hungrier than when I was on a low-carb diet. This is why I ate way too much on the former diet (& got fat) and ate much less on the latter diet (& got slim).

It's thought that Insulin is the only hormone responsible for body-fat storage. This isn't correct.

Insulin makes the body store glucose (from dietary carbohydrates) and amino acids (from dietary proteins) and stops the body from burning fats. Therefore, having chronically-high serum insulin levels (hyperinsulinaemia) is not desirable for people wishing to burn body-fat for fuel.

As we all know, dietary carbohydrate raises serum insulin levels by raising blood glucose. See http://www.mendosa.com/gilists.htm.

However, dietary protein also raises serum insulin levels. See http://www.mendosa.com/insulin_index.htm.

Eating most fats with carbohydrates raises serum insulin levels even higher still, although fats lower the glucose response. See http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/reprint/133/8/2577.pdf. What do junk foods mostly consist of? High-GI carbohydrates + fats. However, omega-3 fats reduce the hyperinsulinaemia caused by the other fats. See http://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/cgi/reprint/53/suppl_1/S166.pdf.

Eating fat on its own does not raise serum insulin levels. See http://intl.ajcn.org/cgi/reprint/75/3/505.pdf. However, it's still possible to gain body-fat by eating too many Calories of dietary fat. Acylation Stimulating Protein (ASP) makes the body store dietary fat as body-fat. See http://www.jlr.org/cgi/reprint/30/11/1727.pdf.

The amount of food that free-living people (i.e. people who are not restrained to a hospital bed) eat depends mostly on their appetites. This is affected by the food that they eat (the low blood glucose that follows hyperinsulinaemia causes severe hunger pangs) and also advertisements. Watch this Google video of Adam Curtis' BBC documentary The Century Of The Self - Part 1 of 4.

I hope that you all had a good Christmas.